History of Enzyme Potentiated
Desensitization (EPD - now LDA in this country) Immunotherapy
W.A. Shrader, Jr., M.D.
Please note:
neither EPD nor LDA are approved by the Food and Drug
Administration.
Summary
Enzyme Potentiated Desensitization (EPD) is a unique method of
immunotherapy, developed in the 1960s, which involves treating all
types of allergy with combinations of a large variety of extremely
low dose allergens. EPD is a cell-mediated type of immunotherapy.
It has been employed to treat multiple conditions and is a long lasting treatment option for allergy and autoimmune
illnesses. It has also been employed for many conditions not
generally thought to be due to any type of allergy or autoimmune
disease. EPD is no longer available in the USA and has been
replaced by Ultra Low Dose Enzyme Activated Immunotherapy (LDA).
This site summarizes the results of treatment with EPD of 10,372
patients for various conditions from 1993 through 2000 by members of
the American EPD Society (AEPDS). The AEPDS was a group of over 70
physicians specifically trained to administer EPD immunotherapy.
From 1993 through 2000, the study was formally supervised by the
Institutional Review Board (IRB) of the Great Lakes College of
Clinical Medicine (GLCCM).
Introduction
Enzyme Potentiated Desensitization (EPD) is a method of
immunotherapy developed by the clinical and academic allergist,
Leonard M. McEwen, M.D., in England in the mid 60's. The
method involves desensitization with combinations of a wide variety
of extremely low dose allergens (10-14 to approximately
10-7, or 1 part in 100 million to as low as 1 part in 1
quadrillion). These allergens are given with the enzyme,
beta-glucuronidase. The beta-glucuronidase likely acts as a
lymphokine, a substance that potentiates the immunizing ability
of the allergens. EPD appears to specifically induce the production
of "activated" T-suppressor cells. These cells
actively turn off the T-helper cells that are acting inappropriately
and producing the symptoms of allergy
Comparison of EPD to conventional
immunotherapy
Conventional "escalating dose" (where
the dose is started "low" - usually 1 to 10,000, and increased over
time to as high as 1 to 10, 1 to 20 or 1 to 100) immunotherapy is
employed in this country primarily to treat hay fever and cat and dust
mite allergy, which are primarily IgE mediated. This type of
therapy works by causing the patient to produce "blocking antibody"
(specific IgG), which inhibits the histamine-releasing ability
(which produces the allergy symptoms) of the mast cell. The higher
the level of blocking antibody that can be produced, the more
successful is the treatment. In order to produce adequate levels of
blocking antibody, studies have shown that it requires
administration of very high doses of allergen. Therefore, treatment
using this method often causes intolerable swelling and other side
effects before clinical efficacy can be attained, and can be
dangerous due to the risk of severe reactions such as anaphylaxis,
massive swelling, collapse and death.
In
England, "conventional" (escalating dose) immunotherapy has now been
banned by the Medicines Commission (26 deaths had been reported)
except when given in a hospital setting where emergency
resuscitation equipment is immediately available. On the other hand,
EPD is allowed to be administered in physicians' offices in
England. Hence there has been a virtual demise of conventional high
dose immunotherapy in England. In the United States, at least 60
deaths have been recorded since treatment began in the 1930s as a
result of conventional immunotherapy, but the actual number is
likely closer to 100.
Deaths from conventional escalating
dose immunotherapy are generally a result of anaphylaxis. This is
due to the extremely high dose of antigen required to produce a
significant clinical effect. EPD immunotherapy, however, is
cell-mediated and extremely low dose. The highest ending dose
("maintenance" dose) of EPD is at least 10 million times less than
the standard maintenance dose for conventional immunotherapy. EPD
immunotherapy is now the only allergy immunotherapy permitted to be
used in a physician's office outside a hospital setting in the
United Kingdom.
The
danger of fatal or life-threatening systemic reactions to EPD
treatment is negligible. Well over 350,000 doses of EPD have been
given worldwide, and again - unlike other types of immunotherapy -
life-threatening reactions to EPD have not been reported
since use was begun over 40 years ago.
Conventional escalating dose
immunotherapy generally does not generally offer long lasting
benefit, and it cannot easily be stopped without the return of
significant symptoms in 3 to 12 months. It has been suggested by
several previous studies of EPD immunotherapy that this method of
treatment can produce much longer lasting desensitization than does
conventional immunotherapy, with treatments lasting as long as 1-5
years. Historically, approximately half of patients who have
responded to EPD were able to stop permanently after between 10 and
20 treatments.
Conventional immunotherapy must
usually be administered twice weekly for the first four to six
months of treatment. Once the very high maintenance dose is
reached, the treatment interval may be extended to once every two
weeks, but rarely less often.
EPD immunotherapy,
on the other hand, is only administered every two months or less
often, according to previous published studies and our 7-year
study. Treatment is required only every two months initially for a
period of approximately 12 months. After that time, the treatment
interval may generally be extended to three months or longer. Most
adults with significant problems require 16 of 18 treatments at
intervals of three months or longer, at which time treatment may be
discontinued or significantly reduced (intervals of a year or less
often are common) for the majority of patients.
EPD
includes mixtures of antigens developed by Dr. McEwen over the past
30 years that may act quite "universally." This means patients
allergic or intolerant to most substances have responded to
treatment. Available EPD mixtures include inhaled pollens, danders,
dust and mites, a wide range of bacteria, fungi, yeast (including
candida species), molds, all foods (except EPD will not
desensitize to raw carrot and raw apple), many food additives, most
common chemicals (except pesticides and herbicides), formaldehyde,
detergents (for contact skin sensitivity), wood terpenes, and
mosquito (which likely cross reacts with other non-venomous
insects). EPD treatment for bee venom anaphylaxis is currently
under investigation in England.
EPD has
the distinct advantage that it effectively treats
a very wide variety of immune and autoimmune disorders (and others
not generally perceived to be immune-related), including illnesses
that respond poorly -- or not at all -- to other methods of
treatment of any kind. Some of the conditions being treated
successfully with EPD include hay fever [8,11, 14,15,25], dust mite
allergy [16,20] perennial rhinitis [6], asthma [6,14,16,20],
urticaria ("hives") [14], eczema (dermatitis) of most all varieties
[14], angioedema (swelling of the face, lips, etc.) [6,14],
anaphylactic reactions (life-threatening swelling, usually involving
the airways) to most known substances [14], food (or food
additive/preservative) allergy or intolerance [7,12], adverse
responses to chemicals ("multiple chemical sensitivity" or "MCS")
[14], ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder) [13,14],
autism, Tourette's syndrome, irritable bowel disorders, Crohn's
Disease, ulcerative colitis [7] migraine and other headaches
[14,16,17,21] rheumatoid arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis and
systemic lupus erythematosis [27], to name just a few.
EPD Study Results |